In the pantheon of film history, there are few franchises as beloved as “Back to the Future.” The trilogy’s whimsical take on time travel and family dynamics made it a cultural touchstone. However, a shadow lingers over the sequels due to the contentious replacement of Crispin Glover with Jeffrey Weissman to play George McFly. This creative and legal controversy remains a pivotal moment in Hollywood’s approach to actor’s rights and image usage.
Marty McFly, portrayed by Michael J. Fox, finds himself unintentionally transported back in time 30 years in the film Back To The Future. In order to return to his own timeline, Marty must devise a plan while also ensuring that his teenage parents unite, otherwise he risks being erased from existence. Back To The Future, a science fiction masterpiece, has stood the test of time and continues to improve. The film boasts impeccable casting, cinematography, editing, and music, and it has even inspired two sequels, a cartoon series, and multiple video games.
Director Robert Zemeckis and writer Bob Gale have firmly decided against creating a Back To The Future Part IV, prioritizing the preservation of the trilogy’s integrity. Throughout the franchise, the replacement of actors in crucial roles has been a notable characteristic. For instance, Elizabeth Shue took over the role of Jennifer from Claudia Wells in Back To The Future Part II. This substitution was so significant that the original ending had to be completely reshot with Shue in Wells’ place.
However, the most renowned case of actor replacement is Eric Stoltz. Initially cast as Marty in Back To The Future due to Michael J. Fox’s unavailability, Stoltz’s portrayal was deemed too intense and lacking the desired comedic tone by Zemeckis and producer Steven Spielberg. Despite filming for approximately six weeks, the decision was made to recast the role with Fox.
The choice was made to discard all of his footage and begin anew with Michael J. Fox, and considering the success of Back To The Future, it’s difficult to find fault with this decision. However, the same cannot be said for Crispin Glover’s replacement in Back To The Future Part II.
Glover’s charmingly eccentric depiction of George is one of the standout moments of the original film, but he had conflicts with Zemeckis during production. He particularly disliked the conclusion, where George and the family are wealthy due to his newfound self-assurance, as Glover believed that associating wealth with happiness sent a negative message.
Despite co-writer Bob Gale’s assertions of a salary standoff, Glover contested these claims, stating he never asked for the alleged million-dollar salary to reprise his role in “Back to the Future Part II.” This disagreement played a pivotal role in his decision not to return, leading to a recasting that would leave audiences largely unaware of the switch. The filmmakers chose to employ footage of Glover from the original and had Weissman don prosthetics, causing Glover to initiate legal action against the production, which resulted in a settlement and changes to Screen Actors Guild regulations regarding the use of an actor’s likeness without consent.
Although the legal dust has settled, the emotional impact persists. Glover has openly criticized the sequel and was deeply disturbed by the unauthorized use of his likeness. The effects of the lawsuit ripple through the industry, ensuring actors’ rights are better protected. Glover’s absence in the “Back to the Future” sequels exemplifies the tension between artistic integrity and commercial success in Hollywood.
Relevant articles:
– TIL Back to the Future’s George McFly was only played by Crispin Glover in the first movie – for parts 2 and 3, it was actor Jeffrey Weissman wearing a Crispin Glover face-mold
, Dec 8, 2023