In the shadows of history, as the Weimar Republic faltered on the brink of collapse, Chancellor Heinrich Brüning stood at the center of a desperate, clandestine gamble to prevent Adolf Hitler’s ascent to power. His plan, audacious and fraught with political peril, was nothing less than the restoration of the German monarchy in the tumultuous year of 1932.
Brüning, a figure still embroiled in historical controversy, served as the chancellor from 1930 to 1932. His tenure coincided with the Great Depression’s crushing impact on Germany, forcing him into a series of deeply unpopular austerity measures. Governing largely through emergency decrees with President Paul von Hindenburg, Brüning’s efforts to navigate the Republic through economic calamity earned him labels varying from the “last bulwark of the Weimar Republic” to its “undertaker.”
In the midst of political chaos and facing the rise of extremist factions, Brüning’s pursuit of a solution led him to an unconventional strategy: the reinstatement of a constitutional monarchy, with Hindenburg positioned as regent. This plan emerged posthumously from Brüning’s memoirs, revealing his intentions to persuade the Reichstag to forgo the 1932 presidential election and invite one of Crown Prince Wilhelm’s sons to the throne upon Hindenburg’s death. This proposed shift to a British-style monarchy could have been, in Brüning’s estimation, the only bulwark strong enough against the tide of Nazism.
It’s noted that Brüning claimed to have secured the support of most major political parties, apart from the Nationalists, Communists, and Nazis, indicating that the plan might have achieved the necessary two-thirds majority for enactment. However, the plan crumbled when Hindenburg, steeped in monarchist sentiment, refused to proceed unless the exiled Kaiser Wilhelm II was reinstated—a condition that was untenable to both domestic and international stakeholders.
The legacy of Heinrich Brüning is further complicated by his foreign policy maneuvers. Despite the internal focus on economic austerity, he sought to reassert Germany’s position on the world stage, challenging the Treaty of Versailles and expanding the nation’s influence in central and eastern Europe. These actions, while driven by nationalistic fervor, failed to yield the foreign loans Germany desperately needed and further strained relations with the international community.
Ultimately, Brüning’s chancellorship concluded ignominiously in May 1932, as he was unceremoniously dismissed by Hindenburg, marking “100 metres before the finish” of his efforts to stave off disaster. His departure cleared the path for political maneuvers that would soon see Hitler appointed as chancellor.
Brüning would later flee Germany, settling in the United States, where he taught at Harvard University and continued to shape the discourse on German and Soviet policies, though often his warnings went unheeded. His death in 1970 and the posthumous publication of his controversial memoirs only deepened the enigma surrounding his role in one of history’s most pivotal moments.
Relevant articles:
– Heinrich Brüning