In the landscape of European justice systems, the Netherlands stands out with its strict interpretation of life sentences—a stark contrast to many of its neighboring countries. Unlike other European nations where life imprisonment often includes a possibility of parole, the Netherlands adheres to a doctrine that is as literal as it is formidable: life means life.
However, in this rigorous context, there remains a shimmer of clemency—the Royal Pardon. This exceptional form of mercy can only be bestowed by a decree from the monarchy, a notion that might seem archaic in today’s democratic societies. Yet, it is the sole avenue for redemption for those ensnared indefinitely by the law’s tightest grip. It’s noteworthy that in recent history, this regal reprieve has been exercised sparingly. Since the 1970s, a mere three pardons have been granted, two of which were given to inmates on the brink of death. As it stands in 2023, approximately 30 individuals are serving life sentences within the Dutch penal system.
The practice of granting life sentences without parole has been scrutinized and debated, considering the European Convention on Human Rights’ stance against inhumane or degrading treatment. Notably, the Dutch Supreme Court in 2016 took a step toward a more humane approach, ruling that life-sentenced prisoners must be allowed to have their cases reviewed no later than 25 years into their incarceration. While this review does not guarantee release, it does inject a dose of hope into otherwise desolate sentences.
Despite this, the Dutch judicial system is known for its precision and restraint. Most murders result in sentences ranging from 12 to 30 years, with life imprisonment reserved for the most heinous of crimes—those marked by recurrence, multitude, or extreme severity. The case of Mohammed Bouyeri, who received a life sentence for the politically charged murder of filmmaker Theo van Gogh in 2005, is a prime example of the rare use of this ultimate sanction.
Relevant articles:
– TIL that The Netherlands is the only country in Europe where life imprisonment actually means life imprisonment. Parole can only be granted by Royal decree.