In a landscape punctuated by periodic violence and humanitarian crises, the Gaza Strip continues to endure a protracted stalemate over ceasefire negotiations between Israel and Hamas. Despite ongoing efforts by mediators from Qatar and Egypt to broker a truce, the discussions appear deadlocked with both parties standing firm on their respective demands. A diplomat described the talks as “stuck but ongoing,” saying that there continues to be “proposals going back and forth.”
Ismail Haniyeh, the Doha-based leader of Hamas, reaffirmed the group’s stance, insisting on “the permanent ceasefire, comprehensive and complete withdrawal of the enemy out of the Gaza Strip, the return of all displaced people to their homes, allowing all aid needed for our people in Gaza, rebuilding the Strip, lifting the blockade and achieving an honorable prisoner exchange deal.” He mentioned that Hamas would not back down from any of its demands for the release of 130 hostages taken by the militant group following the October 7 tragedy in southern Israel.
The Israeli government, under the leadership of Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, has maintained a markedly different vision for the truce’s terms. Israeli officials characterize Hamas’s demands as “delusional,” focusing instead on a temporary halt in fighting and the continued objective to eliminate Hamas’s presence in Gaza altogether. Hamas senior official Basem Naeim told CNN on Monday. “Israel has not agreed to any of (Hamas) requests related to a complete ceasefire, the withdrawal of all forces from the Gaza Strip, even in stages, and the return of all displaced people to their homes.”
Netanyahu’s office outlined an “updated proposal for a temporary truce and hostage release deal,” yet Hamas officials claim to have received no new proposals, casting doubt on the progress of negotiations. “The movement has not received any proposals from the mediators or the occupation (Israel) regarding a ceasefire and a prisoner exchange deal.”
Qatar’s Prime Minister Sheikh Mohammed bin Abdulrahman Al Thani shed light on the deadlock, pinpointing the return of displaced Palestinians to different parts of Gaza as a primary sticking point. “Hamas wants the public to be able to return to the north. This is huge for Hamas and the Israelis are giving them a hard time on that. The Israelis don’t want them (displaced Palestinians) to have freedom of movement.” And Israel’s conditional openness to allowing women and children to return contrasts with its apprehension about men’s return, fearing it might facilitate Hamas’s resurgence in areas where it has been expelled.
Another sticking point, the source said, is whether Palestinian prisoners with life sentences would be part of the release. Hamas wants to free hundreds of high-value detainees serving time for serious terror offenses, including mass killings.
Adding to the complexity is the international dimension. The United Nations Security Council recently passed a resolution mandating an immediate ceasefire in Gaza for the Ramadan period. The resolution represents a pivotal shift in diplomatic endeavors aimed at ceasing the current conflict, concluding a period of five months where multiple attempts at brokering peace were thwarted by U.S. vetoes. U.N. Secretary-General António Guterres emphasized the urgency of implementing the resolution, stating that failure to do so would be “unforgivable.”
The United States, through voices like National Security Council spokesman John Kirby, has expressed frustration over events such as an Israeli strike that resulted in civilian casualties but does not anticipate these impacting the ongoing talks. Contrarily, statements from the White House and the State Department suggest a delicate involvement, with the US criticizing misinformation and warning against unilateral military operations without a plan for civilian safety.
Relevant articles:
– Hamas says it won’t budge on truce demands, blames Israel as Qatar says talks stuck
– Israel-Hamas ceasefire talks are ‘stuck but ongoing,’ sources tell CNN, CNN, Wed, 27 Mar 2024 13:49:00 GMT
– Israel-Hamas ceasefire talks are ‘stuck but ongoing,’ sources tell CNN, Yahoo Singapore News, Sat, 30 Mar 2024 04:04:12 GMT
– Israel Pulls Out Of Gaza Truce Negotiations, Points Finger At Hamas For Escalating Conflict, Benzinga, Wed, 27 Mar 2024 06:19:24 GMT